LESSON #1: IN THIS WEEK AFTER THE OSCARS, LET’S COOL OUR JETS ON THE INSTANTANEOUS “MASTERPIECE” LABEL— During the recent awards season, one article stood out for me when it came to talking about “masterpieces,” and those FF Facebook group members out there know how I feel about those. It preached the kind of temperance I’ve been begging for. A general editorial discussion by Edward Douglas of The Tracking Board followed the high praise for Black Panther. Douglas’s article nails it and matches my heart and mind on the topic. I highly recommend the read.
LESSON #2: NO OSCAR JUGGERNAUT EXISTS GOING ON 14 YEARS— The Shape of Water, despite 13 nominations only won four Academy Awards, including Best Picture at the 90th Academy Awards. No film has won double-digit Oscars since The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King at the 2004 ceremony. The most Oscars won by a single film since was eight by Slumdog Millionaire. If this was a sport, we would call the trend “parity.” If this was civics or government, we would call it “spreading the wealth” and “depth of variety.” I don’t know about you, but I think we need a massive awards winner every now and then to remind us how a truly great film (maybe even a future “masterpiece,” there I said it) can dominate and be the peak of artistic achievement in multiple areas at the same time. Inflated box office number aside, if the last decade of film feels weak in the prestige department compared t the era before it, the lack of big Oscar winners creates that impression.
LESSON #3: CAN WE TRIM THAT LONG SHOW ALREADY?!— Did you notice the annual Honorary Oscar winners were omitted from appearing on the main show this year? Remember when legends would grace the stage and preside over the ceremony in the high-end sideboxes? Go back to this perfect moment of torch-passing and acknowledged respect at the 2002 Oscars when Denzel Washington won his Best Actor award for Training Day on the same night Sidney Poitier, one of his heroes, received his Honorary Oscar:
Moments like that beat Gal Gadot handing out treats to unsuspecting folks watching a movie. Sure, it’s cute, but it’s beneath the importance of these awards. I would have gladly traded any and all of the comedy bits and mostly purposeless montages the Oscars telecasts crams down our viewing throats each year for more genuine and unscripted moments like the Denzel/Sidney one. Now watch Donald Sutherland’s acceptance speech for his Honorary Oscar received at a prior banquet this year.
That’s an Oscar moment better than Helen Mirren rubbing any sexy inanimate object. Want to make the Oscars better? Put the magic and emotion back into the show. Make them important again, not a sideshow.
LESSON #4: POSTSCRIPT, HERE’S WHY THE BOSS BABY WAS AN OSCAR NOMINEE— I didn’t learn this until after the Oscars, but there was a rule change in the nominations process for Best Animated Feature. The category can now be voted on by any Academy member, not just people from that department or discipline. Previously, the only award that had that universal voting like that was Best Picture. This Vox article explains how commercial reach watering down of the category could cause a slow death of independent animation, a small enough niche to be ignored or inaccessible to most general voters. Keep that in mind next year. That still doesn’t explain why The LEGO Batman Movie didn’t get the spot given to The Boss Baby.
LESSON #5: THE NEXT AWARDS SEASON STARTS NOW, SO GET TO KNOW YOUR 2019 OSCAR CONTENDERS— Shameless self-promotion, but I love looking into the crystal ball at what movies coming this calendar year will be the ones standing tall with hardware in their hands at the 91st Academy Awards in 2019. There’s always a Sundance Film Festival darling from January that tours the festival scene all year before a fall Oscar release. Get Out reminded us that a February release can again make it a year to the next Oscars, just like The Silence of the Lambs years ago. Will that film be Black Panther this time around? Well, I’ve got your advance study checklist ready for you. Here are 19 films to keep an eye on for the 2019 Oscars. I see you Damien Chazelle and Steve McQueen! Place your early bets now.
DON SHANAHAN is a Chicago-based film critic writing on his website Every Movie Has a Lesson. As an elementary educator by day, Don writes his movie reviews with life lessons in mind, from the serious to the farcical. He is a proud member and one of the founders of the Chicago Independent Film Critics Circle. As a contributor here on Feelin’ Film, he’s going to expand those lessons to current movie news and trends. Find “Every Movie Has a Lesson” on Facebook, Twitter, Medium, and Creators Media.